The Paradox of Branding: Start Narrow to Grow Wide

In partnership with

Modernize your marketing with AdQuick

AdQuick unlocks the benefits of Out Of Home (OOH) advertising in a way no one else has. Approaching the problem with eyes to performance, created for marketers with the engineering excellence you’ve come to expect for the internet.

Marketers agree OOH is one of the best ways for building brand awareness, reaching new customers, and reinforcing your brand message. It’s just been difficult to scale. But with AdQuick, you can easily plan, deploy and measure campaigns just as easily as digital ads, making them a no-brainer to add to your team’s toolbox.

Learn more now.

Ask a first-time founder who their product is for, and you’ll often hear something like:
“Tech-savvy professionals.”
“Everyone who wants to save time.”
“People who care about quality.”

It’s well-intentioned. Broad appeal feels like the safer bet. After all, who doesn’t want a bigger market?

But here’s the paradox:
If your brand tries to resonate with everyone, it’ll connect with no one.
And if you want to scale wide, you need to start narrow.

Let’s unpack why.

Why Focus Builds Power

Iconic brands don’t start iconic. They earn it by going deep, not wide.

They start by building for someone—not everyone. They zero in on a specific customer, context, and culture, and they get obsessive about delivering value, identity, and clarity to that group.

That depth is what makes the brand stick. It turns first-time users into evangelists—and gives everyone else something to notice, envy, or aspire to.

Real-World Proof

Nike didn’t launch as a global athletic brand. It started by serving elite track athletes—specifically runners at the University of Oregon—through handcrafted shoes made with a waffle iron. They earned grassroots loyalty first, then expanded outward.

Facebook didn’t launch as a social network for everyone. It was only for Harvard students. Then other Ivy Leagues. Then other colleges. Then the world. That exclusivity made it feel premium before it became mainstream.

Yeti wasn’t built for weekend picnic-goers. It was a high-end cooler brand made for serious outdoorsmen—hunters, fishers, and hardcore campers. It owned the rugged premium positioning before becoming a backyard BBQ staple.

Each of these brands started narrow. Each became dominant.

The Psychological Principle Behind It

Narrow branding isn’t just a go-to-market tactic—it’s how our brains work. 

People crave belonging and identity. They want to say: “This is for me.” When a brand speaks directly to a specific audience with a clear point of view, that audience pays attention. They feel like they’re being spoken to directly. They engage. They refer.

That emotional alignment creates:

• Belonging (“This is for people like me.”)
  

• Pride (“I was using this before it was cool.”)
  

• Clarity (“I know what this brand stands for.”)

And here’s the kicker:
Everyone else watches.
Because when people see a brand deeply connect with someone—even if it’s not them—they still remember it. They still feel it. They may even envy it.

It’s that tight focus that creates gravitational pull and draws everyone else in. And what’s more, paradoxically, when outsiders witness the resonance, they start to believe in the brand too.

That’s how cult brands become mass brands. Through deep emotional resonance with a few, not unfocused generic reach to many.

How to Start Narrow Without Staying Small

If we’re being honest, most founders worry that going niche means going nowhere.

But narrowing your brand isn't about limiting potential. It's about creating traction, trust, and story—fast.

Here’s how to do it right:

1. Target a Cultural Micro-Niche

Instead of just thinking about broad demographics (e.g., "millennial women"), niche down and focus on identity-driven tribes—people united by a mindset, aspiration, or mission.

Example:
Oiselle didn’t launch as a general women’s athletic wear brand. It focused on competitive female runners who felt ignored by mainstream sportswear—and built a feminist, high-performance running movement from there.

Action:
Define a tight tribe based on behavior, belief, or unmet need. Be their loudest, proudest advocate.

4. Craft a One-Sentence Rallying Cry

The strongest brands don’t need a full pitch to spread—they just need a sticky sentence that travels. Your one-liner should be easy to remember, fun to say, and crystal clear about the value.

This isn’t just a tagline. It’s the phrase your early adopters will share, and your internal team will rally around.

Example:
RXBAR didn’t say “high-protein, whole-food snack bar.” It just printed its ingredients on the front of its packaging and said: “No B.S.” A line so bold and clear, it turned every wrapper into a brand billboard.

Action:
Write your rallying cry using this formula:

“It’s like [something familiar], but for [specific audience]—and [key benefit or attitude].”

Refine it until it’s punchy enough for a tweet and real enough for a pitch.

3. Design for “Insider” Recognition

Build little cues into your brand that only your niche will instantly get. It creates a bond and a sense of exclusivity.

Example:
Rapha (cycling apparel) doesn’t plaster its brand all over its clothes. Instead, it uses subtle stripe placements and minimal branding—signals only die-hard cyclists will spot.

Action:
Use easter eggs, references, or design language that makes your early customers feel seen and special.

5. Bake Expansion Into Your Brand Values

A focused start doesn’t mean a narrow future. The smartest brands root themselves in values broad enough to support long-term growth.

Example:
Bumble launched as a female-first dating app, but its brand value was bigger: giving women control. That principle enabled its move into friendships (Bumble BFF), business networking (Bumble Bizz), and social advocacy.

Action:
Articulate values that extend beyond your first product. Ask: what does our brand fight for? Believe in? Champion?

Final Thought

Many early brands die not because they think too small—but because they try to do too much, too soon, for too many.

Starting narrow isn’t about limiting your ambition.
It’s about earning the right to go wide—by proving you can matter deeply before trying to matter broadly.

The most magnetic brands in the world didn’t grow because they tried to please everyone.
They grew because they spoke meaningfully to someone.

So if you’re in the early innings of building your brand, don’t panic about reach.
Focus on resonance.
Speak with precision.
And become someone’s favorite—not everyone’s maybe.

The scale will come.

Until next time—build narrow, grow wide.

Best,

Edwin